Pleasant Valley Trail #84 (FR 212)
Clifton / Limestone Gulch — Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests · nearest town Clifton, AZ
- Difficulty
3 of 4, Difficult- Length
- 14 mi
- Route
- Point-to-Point
- Time
- Multi-Day
- Status
- Status unknown
- Permit
- None found
- Season
- Not stated by the Forest Service; a 2009 club report says to run the upper river in the dry season only
Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests — Clifton Ranger District · Pleasant Valley Trail #84, which the Forest Service says is actually Forest Road 212 (Greenlee County tourism calls the northern end Martinez Ranch Road, FR 212).
Pleasant Valley Trail #84 is Forest Road 212 along the San Francisco River north of Clifton, which the Forest Service calls an extremely hazardous road used by high-clearance 4-wheel drive vehicles and not recommended for motorized vehicles. FR 212 crosses the river about 55 times between Clifton, Martinez Ranch and AZ 78, and a 2009 club trip met crossings up to 28 inches deep at low water.
Will your rig make it?
My rig is modified
This route calls for 4LO, 30″ tires or larger, lockers recommended, no armor. Verdicts are computed from the base-trim stock tire and wheelbase on file for each platform against this trail's requirements — the same inputs every time, no opinions mixed in.
Stock rigs we cover: 0 meet it · 0 below · 10 well below
Well below the recommended setup 10
| Rig, stock | What you would add |
|---|---|
| Ford Bronco29″ tires · 92″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Ford F-150 Raptor35″ tires · 133″ – 145.4″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Jeep Cherokee XJ28″ tires · 101.4″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Jeep Gladiator JT31.5″ – 33″ tires · 137.3″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Jeep Wrangler JK30″ – 32″ tires · 95.4″ – 116″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Jeep Wrangler JL31.5″ – 32.7″ tires · 96.8″ – 118.4″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Jeep Wrangler TJ28″ – 30.5″ tires · 93.4″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Ram Power Wagon33″ tires · 149.3″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Toyota 4Runner31.5″ tires · 109.8″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
| Toyota Tacoma31″ tires · 127.4″ – 141″ wheelbase | built rig: lockers, armor, 35s+lockers help |
These are recommendations, not limits. Meets the recommended setup: a stock base trim clears what this route calls for. Below the recommended setup: the listed items are what we recommend, and without them expect more contact, possible damage and a harder recovery. Longer than recommended: the wheelbase is past what the breakover tolerates, so expect contact. Well below: the route is built around modified rigs. Your lift, tires and lockers change the answer, so check your own rig.
The Forest Service says the road is used by high-clearance, 4-wheel drive vehicles but is not recommended for motorized vehicles, and Arizona State Parks repeats that wording. The 2009 club trip ran full-size trucks and SUVs in the dry season; two drivers who did not engage their lockers needed a winch, and one truck lost body cladding on a gravel bank. No source states a tire size, low-range, locker or skid-plate requirement or a wheelbase limit. Low range, lockers recommended and the capable-stock-only value are a conservative reading of 'extremely hazardous'; 30 inches is a floor, not a sourced figure. We list this as not for a stock rig because the Forest Service calls the road extremely hazardous and not recommended for motorized vehicles.
The trail
Pleasant Valley Trail #84 is, in the Forest Service's own words, actually an extremely hazardous road. It is Forest Road 212 along the San Francisco River north of Clifton, used by high-clearance 4-wheel drive vehicles but not recommended for motorized vehicles. The Forest Service gives the approach: the October 1983 flood destroyed the bridge in North Clifton, so drivers cross the river between Sections 19 and 30 to reach Limestone Gulch, then follow FR 212 on the northeast side of the river for a mile. From the trailhead FR 212 runs northwest to Martinez Ranch and down the river to Clifton, crossing it about 55 times, and south to AZ 78, the Mule Creek Road. Arizona State Parks says an old rock smelter ruin stands on the right side in Limestone Gulch, in less than a mile, and the Forest Service warns of old mine shafts and cave-ins in the area.
A Steward Observatory 4x4 club ran the upper river from north Clifton to Martinez Ranch in October 2009. It met crossings up to 28 inches deep at low water, needed two brief winchings on a mud bar and a gravel bank, and rated the trail 3.5 in the dry season on a scale it does not state. The club says to run it only in the dry season. Greenlee County tourism lists Frisco Camp, a dry campsite with tables and fire rings, as the second site on Martinez Ranch Road (FR 212) heading north toward the river.
Named obstacles
- About 55 river crossings — The Forest Service says FR 212 crosses the San Francisco River about 55 times between Martinez Ranch and Clifton. A 2009 club trip met crossings up to 28 inches deep at low water.
- North Clifton bridge washout — The Forest Service says the October 1983 flood destroyed the bridge in North Clifton, so drivers cross the river between Section 19 and Section 30 to approach Limestone Gulch.
- Limestone Gulch and smelter ruin — The Forest Service says to follow FR 212 on the northeast side of the river for a mile to Limestone Gulch. Arizona State Parks says an old rock smelter ruin can be seen on the right side in less than a mile.
- Old mines — The Forest Service warns of several old mines in the area, with shafts and the risk of a cave-in.
- Mud bars and gravel banks — The 2009 club trip needed two brief winchings, one for a vehicle stuck in a mud bar and one for a vehicle that could not climb a bank, and one driver lost body cladding on a gravel bank.
- Martinez Ranch and Frisco Camp — Greenlee County tourism says Frisco Camp, a dry campsite with tables and fire rings, is the second site on Martinez Ranch Road (FR 212) heading north toward the river, near Martinez Ranch where the Blue River meets the San Francisco.
- AZ 78 south end — The Forest Service says FR 212 runs south from the trailhead to AZ 78, known locally as the Mule Creek Road.
How the sources rate it
| Source | Scale | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests, Pleasant Valley Trail #84 (updated July 22, 2025) | text | Actually an extremely hazardous road used by high-clearance, 4-wheel drive vehicles; not recommended for motorized vehicles |
| Arizona State Parks, Eastern AZ OHV Trailheads (Pleasant Valley Trail #84) | text | Extremely hazardous road used by high-clearance 4WD vehicles; not recommended for motorized vehicles |
| Steward Observatory 4x4 Adventures, San Francisco River trip, October 2009 (club's own scale, not stated) | club scale, not stated | 3.5 in the dry season; crossings up to 28 inches deep at low water; dry season only |
| Trail Manual | 1–4 | 3 — Difficult |
The club's 3.5 has no stated scale and covers the river route between Clifton and Martinez Ranch, so it is a weak anchor. The Forest Service calls the road extremely hazardous with about 55 crossings, and the club recorded crossings up to 28 inches deep at low water plus two winchings. Land-manager wording outranks a club report, and this fits Difficult (3). The club drove trucks and SUVs, some with lockers, so nothing opened supports 4 (built rigs only).
Trail Manual scale: 1 Mild — graded dirt or mild two-track. 2 Moderate — rocks, ruts, mild ledges; stock 4x4 with clearance and 4LO. 3 Difficult — ledges, slickrock steps, off-camber; clearance, tires and skid protection matter. 4 Extreme — built rigs only.
What this trail stresses — and what to check
Pack against the list in the Trail tool kit builder.
Water crossings
Before:
- Walk it first. Know where your intake and axle breathers sit.
After:
- Check differential and transfer-case fluid for a milky look; dry the brakes before the pavement.
Before you go
- Land manager: Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests — Clifton Ranger District
- Route: Pleasant Valley Trail #84, which the Forest Service says is actually Forest Road 212 (Greenlee County tourism calls the northern end Martinez Ranch Road, FR 212).. Stay on the numbered route; everything else is closed to motor vehicles.
- Status page: fs.usda.gov
- Pass / permit: None.
- Length: 14 mi — 14 miles is the only length found, from a Singletracks bike-trail listing that copies the Forest Service text and calls the route out-and-back. The Forest Service page opened gives no mileage and describes FR 212 running northwest from the trailhead to Martinez Ranch and down the San Francisco River to Clifton, and south to AZ 78.
- Season: The Forest Service page gives no season or closure. A 2009 club trip says the upper San Francisco River should only be attempted in the dry season and not in wet weather, and still met crossings up to 28 inches deep at low water that October. The forest alerts page checked on 2026-10-30 lists no fire restrictions and three orders: a Scott Reservoir closure (Lakeside Ranger District), a Benny Creek Campground and Southfork Day Use Area closure (Springerville Ranger District), and a forest-wide limit of 14 consecutive days of camping in any 30-day period. None of those orders names this route.
- Cell coverage: unknown
- Water crossings: 55
Nearby trails
Verification
Confidence: High — 5 independent source domains, land-manager or state-agency source on file, last verified 12 days ago.
- 2026-10-30 — unknown · source — The Forest Service Pleasant Valley page (last updated 2025-07-22) lists OHV road riding and calls the road extremely hazardous and not recommended for motorized vehicles, but states no open or closed status. The forest alerts page checked on 2026-10-30 lists no fire restrictions and three orders: a Scott Reservoir closure (Lakeside Ranger District), a Benny Creek Campground and Southfork Day Use Area closure (Springerville Ranger District), and a forest-wide limit of 14 consecutive days of camping in any 30-day period. None of those orders names this route.
Sources
- Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests, Pleasant Valley Trail #84 (extremely hazardous road; FR 212 directions, about 55 river crossings, old mines; updated July 22, 2025) (land-manager, retrieved 2026-10-30)
- Arizona State Parks, Eastern AZ OHV Trailheads (Pleasant Valley Trail #84: extremely hazardous road, rock smelter ruin in Limestone Gulch, Clifton Ranger District) (state-agency, retrieved 2026-10-30)
- Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests, Alerts (no fire restrictions; closure and camping-limit orders listed; none for the Clifton Ranger District roads) (land-manager, retrieved 2026-10-30)
- Steward Observatory 4x4 Adventures, San Francisco River, October 16-19, 2009 (upper river from north Clifton to Martinez Ranch; crossings up to 28 inches; rated 3.5 in the dry season) (field-report, retrieved 2026-10-30)
- Greenlee County tourism, Mule Creek (Arizona Highway 78) (Martinez Ranch Road FR 212, Frisco Camp dry campsite) (guide, retrieved 2026-10-30)
- Singletracks, Pleasant Valley Trail #84 (14 miles, 4x4 surface, out and back; copies the Forest Service text; no rating) (guide, retrieved 2026-10-30)
Written and maintained by an AZ wheeler and driveway wrencher. How we source guides. Trail facts come from the land manager and the sources listed; conditions change. You are responsible for your rig, your line and your recovery.